Floemdata
AI

Claude or ChatGPT? A Practical Selection Guide

How to choose between Claude and ChatGPT: task type, data terms, cost, and a test on your own tasks instead of a leaderboard.

Floemdata · · 3 min read
Venn diagram of two overlapping circles with writing, code, image and audio icons in the overlap

'Which one is better?' has no single answer; model versions change every few months. This article does not declare a winner. It shows how to make the choice yourself.

Where things stand (October 2026)

Anthropic announced Claude Opus 5.5 on its own site on 22 September 2026; by its own account the model leads in agentic coding and knowledge work, costs 40% less to run than Opus 5, has adjustable thinking effort, and a fast mode is offered in Claude Code and the Claude Platform. According to news sources, OpenAI's current model is the GPT-6 series (Astra on 3 September 2026, widely available in ChatGPT in October 2026; not verified). We could not open OpenAI's own announcement pages, so we base OpenAI model names and dates on news sources. Versions may have changed by the time you read this.

Decision criteria

  • Task type: writing, code, analysis, images or voice; check each product's current feature page for each. This article does not claim which one is better at what, because we have no independent measurement we could verify.
  • Data terms: whether the data you enter is used for training, how long it is stored, and the terms of business plans differ by provider; read the contract text.
  • Cost: calculate subscription, API pricing and usage limits against your real monthly usage.
  • Integration: check whether it works with the tools you already use (editor, browser, office apps).

Run your own test with five tasks

  • Pick five real tasks from your daily work (for example a report summary, an email draft, a code fix).
  • Give each task to both tools with the same instructions; do not use personal or confidential data.
  • Have two colleagues score the outputs without knowing which tool produced them: accuracy, usability, editing time.
  • Repeat the test every three months.

In short: choose by your own tasks, not by leaderboards, and set things up so you can work without being locked into one provider.

← All guides